I didn't say anything about the already installed 1/2" ply, I was referring to the 1/2" backer Alan was thinking of using instead of 1/4" backer.
The backer needs 1/4" space around the perimeter and all solid objects. Sheets are also spaced (usually about 1/8") per directions and of course taped etc.
The person who told you the floor is strong enough and therefore you do not need the backer, isn't a tile setter is he? #1 Backers add no structural strength to the floor and #2 it's not a good practice to install tile direct to ply, esp. in areas that will likely see some dampness.
Jaz
_________________________
Tile 4 You..Troy,Michigan U.S.A.
www.tile4you.com KERDI Shower Specialist-DITRA Installs-Containers of TRAVERTINE direct, ship anywhere. SAVE 40-70%
I've NEVER made a mistake, I thought I did once...but I was wrong!